We tested the 5 most popular grilling tools and the results shocked us
By Sarah Mitchell
Last updated:
Summary: You want to grill veggies, shrimp, and bite-sized pieces without losing them through the grates. But which tool actually works best? We put aluminum foil, grill mats, cast iron skillets, skewers, and a rolling grill basket to the test for 30 days. The results blew us away.
#5: Aluminum Foil
Aluminum foil traps all the moisture so your food ends up steaming instead of grilling. You get zero sear marks, no smoky flavor, and under high heat, the foil breaks down and leaches metals right into your food. Single-use waste that costs you money every time and harms the environment.
The Verdict
The food gets steamed, not grilled. No grill marks, no flavor. Leaches metals under high heat. Avoid.
#4: Grill Mats
Grill mats completely block the fire, so your food never makes direct contact with the heat. The result? Flat, flavorless food that might as well have been cooked in a frying pan indoors. You might as well have stayed inside the kitchen. Plus, they wear out fast and can release chemicals under high heat.
Verdict
Defeats the whole purpose of grilling. Blocks all direct heat. Food tastes like you cooked it on the stove.
#3: Cast Iron Skillet
Cast iron skillets technically work, but they trap all the juices inside so you miss out on that smoky flavor that comes from drippings hitting the coals. The food tastes pan-fried, not grilled. Plus, they weigh 7+ pounds, take up half the grilling surface, and require hand washing with special oil after every use.
Verdict
It works, but the food tastes pan-fried. Heavy, hogs half the grill, and requires high-maintenance care. You might as well have stayed inside.
#2: Skewers
Skewers give you direct contact with the fire, but you can only cook a tiny amount at a time and they hog all your grill space. You have to waste time threading every single piece, and they annoyingly spin around when you try to flip them. Great for restaurant kebabs, totally impractical for backyard grilling at home.
Verdict
Good flavor but impractical. Low capacity, long prep time, and takes up way too much space. Not worth the hassle for everyday grilling.
#1: BRYNs Rolling Grill Basket
BRYNs stainless steel rolling grill basket shows what a real grilling tool can do. The open wire mesh design lets the flames through for authentic sear marks, while the holes are small enough that nothing falls through. But the best part is the flavor. When you grill with the basket, juices drip down onto the coals, vaporize into smoke, and rise back up through the holes, infusing everything inside with an authentic, smoky grill flavor. Screw on the handle, roll it, and everything cooks evenly. Dishwasher safe and backed by a lifetime warranty.
Verdict — Winner
The only tool that delivers authentic smoky grill flavor. Direct heat, no dropped pieces, dishwasher safe, lifetime warranty. Superior across all criteria.
The winner is clear.
After 30 days of testing, BRYNs Rolling Grill Basket truly stood out. The only tool that delivers authentic smoky grill flavor without sacrificing convenience. Right now 40% off, free shipping, and a lifetime warranty.
🎁 HANDLE + HOOK INCLUDED 🎁
GET 40% OFF
TAILGATE SALE
*Due to extremely high demand, stock may run out faster.
OFFER ENDS IN:
:
:
Try it today with a lifetime warranty!